A serious car accident in Schaumburg can leave you with injuries that take months to heal, but the insurance company might still say the crash did not cause your medical problems. This often comes up after accidents where people have neck or back injuries, concussions, joint damage, or their existing conditions get worse. When an insurer disputes causation, it does not always mean they deny the accident happened. Instead, they might say your injuries were already there, happened because of normal aging, came from something else, or are not serious enough to be linked to the crash. When this happens, I work to gather the medical and factual evidence needed to show the connection between the accident and your injuries.
Causation means showing a legal link between someone else’s negligence and the injury you want compensation for. In a typical Illinois car accident case, it is not enough to prove another driver caused the crash. I also need to show that the crash caused or played a major role in your injuries and losses.
Insurance companies focus on this issue because if they can break the link between the crash and your injury, they can lower the value of your claim. For example, the insurer might agree their driver rear-ended you but say your herniated disc was caused by aging, not the accident. In this case, who caused the accident may not be in question, but whether the accident caused your injury becomes the main issue.
Insurers often go through medical records to find anything that lets them argue the accident did not cause your injury. They may use things like past neck pain, back treatment, arthritis, degenerative disc disease, earlier accidents, work injuries, sports injuries, or even a gap in your treatment to challenge your claim.
The insurer might also look at what you said right after the accident. If you told the officer you felt “okay” at the scene but started having a lot of pain hours later, the insurance company may claim your symptoms are not related. But this ignores the fact that some injuries only become obvious after the adrenaline wears off and inflammation sets in.
I examine the full timeline rather than a single statement or isolated medical record. The onset of symptoms, progression of pain, diagnostic findings, treatment recommendations, and physician opinions can all help establish a consistent causal connection.
Medical records are often one of the most important parts of a case where causation is disputed. Emergency room notes, primary care records, orthopedic and neurological exams, MRIs, CT scans, X-rays, physical therapy notes, and surgery recommendations can all help show how your condition changed after the accident.
I pay close attention to what your treating doctors say about causation. If a doctor explains that the accident caused, made worse, or sped up a condition, that can be very important, especially if it matches the medical evidence and your treatment history.
The insurance company might get its own medical review or ask for an exam by a doctor who does not usually treat you. That doctor might say the accident only caused a temporary strain or that your ongoing symptoms are not related. When this happens, it is important to carefully compare all the opinions and evidence instead of just accepting what the insurer says.
Many adults already have some wear and tear in their spine, joints, or other parts of the body before a car accident. Just having a preexisting condition does not mean the insurance company is right to deny responsibility.
An accident can make an existing medical condition worse and cause symptoms that were minor, stable, or not there before. For example, someone might have degenerative disc disease on an MRI but had no real pain before the crash. If the accident makes that condition start causing pain and leads to major treatment, the worsening of the condition can be a key part of the injury claim.
I compare the person’s health and functional abilities before and after the accident. Prior records, employment history, physical activity, medical appointments, and witness testimony may help show that the collision created a meaningful change.
A delay in seeking treatment or a lengthy gap between appointments can make causation more difficult to prove. Insurers often argue that someone who was truly injured would have sought care immediately or continued treatment without interruption.
There are many good reasons why someone might have a gap in treatment. You might not have health insurance, have trouble getting an appointment, think the pain will go away, have family duties, or not be able to miss work. These reasons may need to be explained and documented.
When I evaluate a claim, I consider the entire treatment history and the reason for any interruptions. Consistent reporting of symptoms and credible explanations for delays can help counter an insurance company’s attempt to use treatment gaps as evidence that an injury was unrelated to the accident.
Medical evidence is essential, but the circumstances of the collision can also matter. Photographs showing substantial vehicle damage, video recordings, witness accounts, crash reports, airbag deployment, towing records, and other evidence may help demonstrate the forces involved.
An insurer may sometimes argue that a relatively low-speed collision could not have caused a particular injury. Vehicle damage alone, however, does not provide a complete picture of what happened to a person’s body during an impact. Age, seating position, head movement, prior physical condition, restraint use, and the direction of impact can all influence the resulting injury.
I look at the accident evidence together with the medical record instead of treating those issues separately.
A disputed causation case can become far more complicated than a routine insurance claim. It may require detailed review of years of medical records, consultation with treating doctors, comparison of diagnostic studies, preparation of medical chronologies, and careful analysis of the insurer’s medical opinions.
A lawyer can also help identify weaknesses in the carrier’s causation arguments. An insurance company may emphasize a prior MRI showing degeneration while ignoring the fact that you were functioning normally before the crash. It may point to an old complaint of back pain even though you had no treatment for years before the accident.
My role is to present your medical history accurately while showing how the collision changed your condition, treatment needs, ability to work, and everyday life.
Causation should also be distinguished from comparative negligence. Under 735 ILCS 5/2-1116, Illinois generally allows an injured person to recover damages if that person’s contributory fault is not more than 50 percent of the total fault causing the injury. Any recovery may then be reduced according to the injured person’s percentage of responsibility.
That issue concerns who was responsible for causing the accident. Medical causation concerns whether the accident caused the injuries being claimed. An insurer may dispute one issue, both issues, or neither, which is why each part of the claim should be evaluated separately.
It means the insurer is challenging the connection between the collision and your medical condition. The company may argue that your injury existed before the crash, resulted from ordinary degeneration, came from a previous accident, or developed for some unrelated reason.
This does not necessarily mean your claim is invalid. I would examine your pre-accident medical history, post-accident symptoms, diagnostic testing, physician opinions, treatment timeline, and the circumstances of the collision. When those pieces of evidence consistently point to the crash as the cause or aggravating factor, they can help counter the insurer’s position.
Potentially, yes. Illinois personal injury claims can involve aggravation of preexisting conditions. The important question is often whether the accident made the condition worse or caused new symptoms, limitations, or treatment needs.
I may compare medical records from before and after the collision to determine whether there was a measurable change. If you had mild occasional discomfort before the accident but required injections, surgery, or extensive therapy afterward, that difference can become significant evidence.
Not automatically, but a delay can create an argument for the insurance company. The carrier may claim that someone who waited several days or weeks to seek treatment must not have been seriously injured.
Why there was a delay is significant. Some injuries get worse over time, and some people hope their pain will go away on its own. Sometimes, money issues, transportation problems, work, or trouble getting an appointment can also cause delays. I check if your medical records show a steady pattern of symptoms.
Yes, and this is a common argument in neck and back injury claims. Degenerative changes often appear on imaging studies, especially as people get older, even when they were not experiencing serious symptoms before an accident.
The question is not simply whether degeneration existed. I focus on whether the collision caused new symptoms, worsened an existing condition, accelerated the need for treatment, or changed your physical abilities. Comparing your condition before and after the crash can be extremely important.
The insurer’s medical opinion is one piece of evidence, not necessarily the final word. A doctor retained by the carrier may review records or examine you and conclude that your injuries were minor, temporary, or unrelated to the crash.
I would compare that opinion with your treating physicians’ findings, diagnostic studies, treatment history, and functional limitations. Differences in the medical evidence may need to be addressed directly during settlement negotiations or litigation.
A lawyer can organize the evidence needed to show how the accident and injury are connected. This may include medical records, imaging studies, physician opinions, prior medical history, accident photographs, witness statements, employment records, and documentation showing how your daily activities changed.
I also look for inconsistencies in the insurer’s position. A carrier may argue that an injury was preexisting even though there was little or no treatment before the crash. Presenting the complete medical timeline can make the difference between an isolated record being taken out of context and a fair evaluation of what actually happened.
When an insurance company disputes causation, the disagreement can affect nearly every part of your personal injury claim. A carrier may acknowledge that its insured caused the accident while refusing to accept responsibility for your surgery, therapy, injections, lost income, or continuing pain. I can examine the medical records, prior health history, diagnostic evidence, accident circumstances, and the insurance company’s arguments to determine how the claim can be supported.
SJ INJURY LAW represents people injured in Schaumburg and surrounding northwest suburban communities, including Arlington Heights, Buffalo Grove, Des Plaines, Elk Grove Village, Mount Prospect, Northbrook, Palatine, Rolling Meadows, Prospect Heights, Wheeling, Park Ridge, Rosemont, and Glenview. The firm also serves clients throughout Chicago and communities across Illinois.
If an insurance company is claiming that your injuries were preexisting, degenerative, unrelated to the collision, or caused by something other than the accident, contact SJ INJURY LAW, a Schaumburg car accident attorney, to discuss your legal options. Contact our Schaumburg car accident attorney at SJ INJURY LAW by calling (847) 434-3555 to receive your free consultation.
At SJ Injury Law, we’re ready to help you Claim Your Justice™.
Client injured by a distracted driver who was texting at the time…
Student was injured and fractured several bones and required surgery to…
While at work operating a piece of manufacturing equipment, the safety…
Woman was bitten on her face by what she believed to be a vicious…
Our client suffered a back injury and will undergo spine surgery…
Client's vehicle was forced into oncoming traffic, colliding with a semi-truck...
We are highly experienced personal injury lawyers. We know how to help accident victims receive the full financial compensation they deserve. Our Winning Team is focused, dedicated, and sensitive to each of our client's needs. We are here to help you 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.